Kidney Stone Treatment: Methods Based on Stone Size and Location
Kidney stone treatment is not the same for everyone. For one patient, drinking plenty of water and waiting a few weeks is enough, while another may need the stone broken up with sound waves or removed with closed surgery. The roadmap is determined by the size of the stone, its location, its composition and the patient’s general health together.
Kidney stones are a common problem. Our country is among the regions where stone disease is frequently seen, and about one in ten adults experiences a stone problem at some point in life. Sometimes a stone is found incidentally without causing any complaints; at other times it makes itself known through severe flank pain (renal colic), blood in the urine or a urinary tract infection.
In this article, we answer step by step, in line with current international guideline recommendations, the question “I have a kidney stone: will it pass on its own, or do I need surgery?”
What Determines the Method in Kidney Stone Treatment?
To choose the right method, the characteristics of the stone and the patient’s condition are evaluated together. The factors below are decisive in this choice.
Kidney stone size
Kidney stone size is the largest diameter of the stone, measured in millimetres (mm). It is the most important factor determining both the likelihood that the stone will pass on its own and the method required. The smaller the stone, the greater its chance of passing through the urinary tract on its own; the larger it is, the more likely an intervention becomes. The most accurate measurement is made with computed tomography; on ultrasound, a stone may appear at a different size than it really is.
Stone location
A stone may be in the upper, middle or lower part of the kidney, in the renal pelvis, where the kidney collects urine, or in the tube that connects the kidney to the bladder (ureter). In stones in the lower part of the kidney, it is harder for the broken fragments to be passed out. In ureteral stones, the closer the stone is to the bladder, the higher its chance of passing on its own.
Stone composition and hardness
Most kidney stones contain calcium; uric acid, infection-related (struvite) or cystine stones are seen less often. The density measured on computed tomography gives an idea of how hard the stone is. In very hard stones, the success of breaking the stone from outside the body decreases. Uric acid stones, on the other hand, can sometimes be dissolved with medication.
Patient-related factors
Kidney function, urinary tract infection, use of blood-thinning medication, pregnancy, a solitary kidney, excess weight and congenital structure of the urinary tract affect the decision. For example, extracorporeal stone breaking is not performed during pregnancy. In patients with marked excess weight, endoscopic methods are considered first.
Kidney stone symptoms
The most typical kidney stone symptoms are as follows:
Severe, wave-like pain spreading from the flank and lower back to the groin
Nausea and vomiting
Blood in the urine (visible to the eye or detected on testing)
Frequent urination and burning during urination
Fever and chills (if an infection is present)
Kidney stone diagnosis
The most commonly used methods for kidney stone diagnosis are as follows:
Ultrasonography: It involves no radiation and is the first-line method. It shows whether there is dilation of the kidney (hydronephrosis).
Low-dose non-contrast computed tomography (CT): It is the method that shows the location, size and hardness of the stone most accurately. It is recommended to confirm the diagnosis in sudden flank pain.
Plain X-ray (flat abdominal film): It shows some stones and is particularly helpful in follow-up.
Urine and blood tests: Infection, kidney function and inflammation values are checked; a urine culture is taken.
During pregnancy, ultrasonography is the first choice; if necessary, magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) is used as the second step, and low-dose tomography as the last option.
General framework by size and location
The table below summarizes the general approach in international guidelines. The final decision is made individually for each patient.

Small Stones: Observation and Medical Therapy
Does a kidney stone pass on its own?
The answer to the question does a kidney stone pass on its own depends largely on the size and location of the stone. Studies show that about three-quarters of ureteral stones smaller than 5 mm, and about 60 percent of those 5 mm and larger, pass on their own. For small stones in the lower part of the ureter, this rate approaches 90 percent. Stones larger than 10 mm are not generally expected to pass on their own.
Small stones inside the kidney that cause no complaints do not always require immediate treatment. These stones can be monitored with regular check-ups. If the stone grows, blocks the urinary tract, or causes infection or pain, treatment is planned.
The observation period and plenty of fluids
In patients whose pain is under control, who have no fever and whose kidney function is normal, it is usually possible to wait 4–6 weeks for the stone to pass. During this time, whether the stone is moving and whether the kidney is dilated is checked with periodic imaging.
During the observation period, drinking 2.5–3 litres of fluid per day is recommended. The urine can be passed through a strainer to catch the stone when it passes. Analysis of the stone reveals its type and allows recommendations for preventing recurrence to be personalized.
Kidney stone medication
When kidney stone medication is mentioned, the first thing that comes to mind is the alpha blocker group of drugs. These drugs relax the muscle of the urinary canal (ureter) and make it easier for the stone to pass. The guidelines recommend this treatment particularly for stones larger than 5 mm in the lower part of the ureter. Although this use is not listed in the drug’s package insert, it is scientifically supported.
Temporary side effects such as dizziness, low blood pressure and, in men, no semen being released during ejaculation may occur. For this reason, the drug must be used only on a physician’s recommendation.
In uric acid stones, the stone can be dissolved with drugs that make the urine alkaline. During this treatment, the patient monitors the acidity level (pH) of their urine at home with test strips, and the drug dose is adjusted accordingly.
There is no strong scientific evidence for herbal mixtures and “stone-passing cures” recommended for kidney stone passing. Some of these products can harm the kidney or interact with the medications being used.
Pain control
In severe pain during a stone attack, the first choice is anti-inflammatory painkillers (non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs, NSAIDs). In choosing the drug, cardiovascular disease, stomach problems and kidney function are taken into account. For pain that does not subside with these drugs, second-line painkillers are used. Pain that cannot be controlled with any medication indicates that an intervention is needed to relieve the kidney or remove the stone.
When is intervention needed without waiting?
In the following situations, the stone is not expected to pass, and treatment is planned promptly:
Pain that cannot be controlled with medication
Fever, chills and signs of infection
Blockage of the urinary tract by the stone and dilation of the kidney
Blockage in a solitary kidney or on both sides
Deterioration in kidney function
A stone that has not progressed despite 4–6 weeks of observation
A kidney that is blocked by a stone and infected is an emergency. In these patients, urine flow is first relieved with a temporary stent or a thin tube placed into the kidney through the skin (nephrostomy), and antibiotics are started immediately. Definitive treatment of the stone is performed after the infection has completely cleared.
Medium-Sized Stones: ESWL and Endoscopic Methods
For medium-sized stones that are not expected to pass on their own or that cause complaints, two main options stand out: breaking the stone from outside the body with shock waves, and endoscopic laser treatment performed by entering through the urinary tract.
Stone breaking with ESWL
Stone breaking with ESWL (extracorporeal shock wave therapy) is the focusing of shock waves on the stone through a head in contact with the skin, breaking the stone into small fragments. The position of the stone is followed with X-ray or ultrasound throughout the procedure. The fragments are passed in the urine over the following days and weeks. The procedure requires no incision; it is usually performed on an outpatient basis, and the patient returns home the same day.
ESWL gives good results in kidney stones up to 20 mm and in some ureteral stones; however, its success is limited in stones in the lower part of the kidney. The hardness of the stone and the distance between the skin and the stone also affect the result. Some patients may need more than one session. Routine antibiotics are not required in patients with a clean urine culture.
ESWL is not performed in the following situations:
Pregnancy
An uncorrected bleeding disorder or blood-thinning treatment that cannot be stopped
An uncontrolled urinary tract infection
Marked excess weight or skeletal abnormalities that prevent targeting of the stone
An arterial dilation (aneurysm) near the stone
A narrowing or blockage in the urinary tract below the stone
Drinking plenty of fluids after ESWL helps the broken fragments pass. Sometimes the fragments can line up one after another in the ureter and cause a blockage (steinstrasse); in this case, an additional procedure may be needed.
RIRS surgery: Kidney stone breaking with laser
RIRS surgery (laser stone fragmentation with a flexible endoscope) involves reaching the inside of the kidney with a thin, flexible endoscope advanced through the urethra and breaking up the stone under direct vision. No incision is made anywhere on the body. In kidney stone breaking with laser, a holmium or thulium fiber laser is used; the stone can be turned into dust, or broken into small pieces and removed with special baskets. The procedure is performed under anaesthesia, and patients are mostly discharged the next day.
RIRS stands out in the following situations:
Kidney stones up to 20 mm, especially lower pole stones
Hard stones for which ESWL has failed or is unsuitable
Patients who cannot stop blood-thinning medication
Patients with marked excess weight
RIRS has an advantage over ESWL in terms of the chance of being stone-free in a single session; on the other hand, its complication rate is slightly higher. In stones larger than 20 mm, RIRS can be performed if PCNL is not suitable, but the likelihood of needing a second session increases.
Lower pole kidney stone
The lower part of the kidney (lower pole) is an area where broken fragments cannot easily drain because of gravity. For this reason, in the treatment of a lower pole kidney stone larger than 10 mm, RIRS or PCNL, in which the stone is cleared under direct vision, is recommended instead of ESWL. Lower pole stones smaller than 10 mm that cause no complaints can be monitored with annual check-ups.
Ureteral stones
Ureteroscopy is frequently used for stones in the ureter. The stone is reached with a thin endoscope advanced through the urethra, and the stone is broken with a laser or removed whole. Ureteroscopy is the leading option especially for stones in the lower and middle parts of the ureter and for ureteral stones larger than 10 mm. For small stones in the upper ureter, ESWL is also an option.
Double-J stent
A double-J stent is a thin plastic tube with curled ends, placed between the kidney and the bladder, which preserves urine flow. Routine stent placement is not recommended after uncomplicated ureteroscopy. A stent is placed temporarily in situations such as oedema or injury in the ureter, remaining stone fragments, infection, a solitary kidney or a prolonged procedure.
Frequent urination, blood in the urine or mild flank pain during the stent period are mostly temporary; alpha blocker drugs can be used to relieve these complaints. To avoid forgetting the stent, the date of its removal must be planned.
Large Stones: PCNL Surgery and Follow-Up After Treatment
What is PCNL surgery?
PCNL surgery (percutaneous nephrolithotomy) is a closed method in which the kidney is reached through an approximately 1 cm tract made in the back, and the stone is broken and removed directly. International guidelines recommend PCNL as the first choice for large kidney stone treatment in kidney stones larger than 20 mm. Staghorn stones, which branch and fill the inside of the kidney, are also in this group.
Before surgery, computed tomography is performed to see the extent of the stone and the structure of the kidney; the urine culture and blood values are evaluated. The surgery is performed under general anaesthesia. After the kidney is reached, the stone is seen with a camera and broken, and the fragments are removed.
PCNL provides a high stone-free rate in a single session in large stones and offers much faster recovery than open surgery. Bleeding and infection are the main risks; the need for blood transfusion and injury to neighbouring organs are rare.
Mini PCNL and other options
Mini PCNL is PCNL performed with thinner instruments through a narrower tract. It reduces blood loss, and the stone-free rate is similar to standard PCNL; however, the operating time may be slightly longer. In suitable patients, tubeless PCNL, in which no drain is left in the kidney at the end of the surgery, can be performed, and this approach shortens the hospital stay. In some complex stones, combined methods in which PCNL and flexible endoscopy are used together in the same session may be preferred.
Hospital stay and recovery
The hospital stay after PCNL is usually 1–3 days. A drain (nephrostomy tube) or a stent may be left in the kidney at the end of the surgery. Patients mostly return to daily activities within a week; heavy lifting and strenuous exercise are postponed for about 2–4 weeks. Recovery after RIRS and ureteroscopy is shorter, and ESWL is mostly performed on an outpatient basis.
Whichever method is chosen, after kidney stone surgery, a physician must be contacted without delay in case of fever, increasing pain, bleeding with clots in the urine or inability to urinate.
For those using blood thinners
Whether blood-thinning medications will be stopped before surgery is decided together with the physician who prescribed the drug. In situations where the blood thinner cannot be stopped and the stone absolutely must be removed, flexible endoscopic treatment (RIRS), the method with the lowest bleeding risk, is preferred.
Preventing kidney stone recurrence
If no precautions are taken, a new stone develops within 5–10 years in about half of treated patients. The general measures recommended in the guidelines for preventing kidney stone recurrence are as follows:
Drinking 2.5–3 litres of fluid per day, preferably water, and keeping the daily urine volume above 2.5 litres
Limiting daily salt intake to 4–5 grams
Not cutting out calcium; getting 1,000–1,200 mg of calcium per day from food
Consuming animal protein, especially red meat, in moderation
Reducing sugary and carbonated drinks
Maintaining ideal weight and doing regular physical activity
Analysis of the stone that has passed or been removed is recommended for every patient. Patients who frequently pass stones, who develop stones at a young age, who have a family history of stones, who have a solitary kidney, or who form uric acid, cystine or infection stones are considered high-risk. In these patients, a metabolic evaluation with two separate 24-hour urine tests is performed at least 3 weeks, preferably 3 months, after the attack. Dietary and medication recommendations are personalized according to these results.
Follow-up after treatment
Whichever method is used, a check is performed after treatment with ultrasonography, plain X-ray or tomography. Small stone fragments remaining in the kidney are monitored because they may grow over time. Even if there are no complaints, regular check-ups ensure that new stones are caught while they are small.
Frequently Asked Questions About Kidney Stone Treatment
At how many mm does a kidney stone need surgery?
There is no single cut-off value. In general, ureteral stones smaller than 5 mm mostly pass on their own; for stones larger than 10 mm, an intervention such as ESWL, RIRS or PCNL is usually required. For kidney stones larger than 20 mm, the first choice is PCNL. However, even if the stone is small, treatment is carried out without waiting if there is uncontrolled pain, fever, blockage or deterioration in kidney function.
Does kidney stone breaking (ESWL) hurt?
During ESWL, there may be a stinging or tapping sensation in the area where the shock waves are applied. In most patients, this sensation is easily controlled with a painkiller or light sedation; general anaesthesia is usually not needed. In the days after the procedure, cramp-like pain and blood in the urine may be seen as the fragments pass. These complaints usually resolve within a few days.
Can a stone form again after kidney stone surgery?
Kidney stone surgery clears the existing stone but does not remove the tendency to form stones. If no precautions are taken, a new stone develops within 5–10 years in about half of patients. Drinking plenty of fluids, restricting salt, a balanced diet, stone analysis and, in high-risk patients, metabolic evaluation significantly reduce this risk.
Is ESWL or RIRS better?
Both methods have their place. ESWL is an outpatient method that requires no incision or anaesthesia; however, its success decreases in hard stones and stones in the lower part of the kidney. RIRS surgery is a method with a higher chance of being stone-free in a single session, but it requires anaesthesia. The choice is made by evaluating the size, location and hardness of the stone together with the patient’s preferences.
Should a kidney stone be treated if it causes no pain at all?
Not always. Small stones that cause no complaints can be monitored with regular check-ups. If the stone grows, blocks the urinary tract, or causes infection or pain, treatment is recommended. The size and location of the stone and the patient’s occupation and living conditions are also taken into account in this decision.
How is a kidney stone treated during pregnancy?
During pregnancy, the first choice for diagnosis is ultrasonography. Most stones can be monitored with plenty of fluids and suitable painkillers. If treatment is needed, a temporary stent, nephrostomy or, in experienced hands, ureteroscopy can be performed. ESWL is not performed during pregnancy.
How long does a double-J stent stay in, and does it cause pain?
The duration of a stent varies from a few days to a few weeks depending on the nature of the procedure. During the stent period, frequent urination, mild pain in the flank area while urinating and blood in the urine may be seen; these complaints can mostly be relieved with medication. It is very important not to forget the stent; the date of its removal must be planned.
How much water should I drink for a kidney stone?
To prevent stone formation, drinking 2.5–3 litres of fluid per day and keeping the urine volume above 2.5 litres per day is recommended. The best fluid is water; sugary and carbonated drinks should be reduced. Fluid intake should be increased in hot weather and in situations where sweating increases. In diseases that require fluid restriction, such as heart or kidney failure, the amount is determined with the physician.
The most suitable method for your kidney stone is determined by evaluating your imaging results, your complaints and your general health together. If you have complaints such as flank pain, blood in the urine or fever, we recommend that you see a urology specialist.
.png)



Comments